FWIW my favorite old whites include a '77 Joseph Phelps Chardonnay, consumed in about '88, and an '80 Dom Perignon opened in '95.
In Reply to: Re: Chardonnays tend to get a little too mellow after only a couple of years aging IMO... posted by mkuller on March 03, 2004 at 14:01:13:
I disagree. It seems to me that the big oaky vanilla monsters are the soft ones that don't age. A Stony Hill (mentioned in the thread) which is made with a light hand on the oak and no malolactic fermentation is a good ager. As is the similarly vinted Trefethen. And a Grgich Hills needs at least four years to come into its own. Some of the oak/tannin can preserve a chardonnay but for what I've tasted you tend to get a slightly astringent apple juice (minus the fruitiness) when you put away most CA chards for more than three years. Whites with firm acid, rather than lots of new oak, are better agers in my opinion.FWIW my favorite old whites include a '77 Joseph Phelps Chardonnay, consumed in about '88, and an '80 Dom Perignon opened in '95.
Follow Ups: